Download Article
To Suggested Citation
Suggested Citation
Hydock, C., Paharia, N. & Blair, S. (2021). Should Your Brand Pick a Side? How Market Share Determines the Impact of Divisive Corporate Political Stances. NIM Marketing Intelligence Review, 13(2), 26-31. https://doi.org/10.2478/nimmir-2021-0013

Register for our Newsletter

NIM Marketing Intelligence Review – Brand Activism

Should Your Brand Pick a Side? How Market Share Determines the Impact of Divisive Corporate Political Stances

Authors

  • Chris Hydock, Assistant Professor of Marketing, California Polytechnic State University, Orfalea College of Business, chydock@calpoly.edu
  • Neeru Paharia, Associate Professor or Marketing, Georgetown University, McDonough School of Business, np412@georgetown.edu
  • Sean Blair, Assistant Professor or Marketing, Georgetown University, McDonough School of Business, sean.blair@georgetown.edu
Download Article

Keywords: Branding, Brand activism, Corporate Political Advocacy, Identity-based Consumption, Market Share, Political Orientation

Abstract

When the public opinion on a social matter is divided, it is riskier for large brands to engage in activism than for small brands. As long as a brand’s initial market share is sufficiently small, engaging in activism can result in a net increase in customers even if the brand takes a stance that consumers overwhelmingly oppose. In contrast, large brands can lose more than they gain, even when opponents and supporters are in balance. Product quality or competitive prices are no insurance against taking the wrong stances. Consumers are willing to trade off price and quality for political values. Therefore, brands cannot dismiss the consequences of politics, even if they hold a traditional competitive advantage in price or quality.

Authors

  • Chris Hydock, Assistant Professor of Marketing, California Polytechnic State University, Orfalea College of Business, chydock@calpoly.edu
  • Neeru Paharia, Associate Professor or Marketing, Georgetown University, McDonough School of Business, np412@georgetown.edu
  • Sean Blair, Assistant Professor or Marketing, Georgetown University, McDonough School of Business, sean.blair@georgetown.edu
Share Publication
Suggested Citation
Hydock, C., Paharia, N. & Blair, S. (2021). Should Your Brand Pick a Side? How Market Share Determines the Impact of Divisive Corporate Political Stances. NIM Marketing Intelligence Review, 13(2), 26-31. https://doi.org/10.2478/nimmir-2021-0013


Other articles of the MIR issue “Brand Activism”

Here you can find more exciting articles of this issue.

To the entire issue

Brand Activism Is Here to Stay: Here’s Why

Brand activism involves a publicly stated position and goes beyond simply fulfilling a social responsibility. It seeks to proactively cha...

Go to article

Turning Social Risk to Your Brand’s Advantage

Employment practices, civic responsibilities, philanthropy, environmental stewardship, the conduct of corporate executives and employees,...

Go to article

Boycott or Buycott: The Aftermath of Corporate Activism

Some stakeholders, notably investors, might be worried that debatable activism interferes with the goal of making profits. Therefore, the...

Go to article

Lobbying and the Like: Managing the Regulatory Environment

Companies not only stand up for or against specific matters in plain sight of the customer, they also pursue their interests less publicl...

Go to article

Tweeter-in-Chief Donald J. Trump: The Story of the Downfall of a Brand

Trump’s frustration with mainstream “fake news” media led him to focus his communications on social media and Twitter in particular. An...

Go to article

Purpose Beyond Profit: Things That Matter When Millennials Go Job Hunting

In a survey of future leaders, millennials answered what motivates them in their careers. Having a positive impact on society was the mos...

Go to article

(Cass) Bayes Business School: Rebranding Due to Slavery Links

The killing of George Floyd by a police officer in June of 2020 put the spotlight on brands with any history of racial injustice. One of...

Go to article

Latest issues

2024-10

Platform Business

Go to issue

2024-04

Generative AI - Reshaping the Marketing Landscape

Go to issue
Scroll to top